Evaluating Open and Closed Vitrification Systems: Impacts on Oocyte Competence and Cryopreservation Practices

 Abstract:

Open and closed vitrification systems are commonly used for oocyte cryopreservation, but their impact on oocyte competence is not well understood. This study compares these systems, examining laboratory and clinical outcomes and the influence of cooling and warming rates. A systematic review of English-language studies up to January 2023 was conducted, involving 23 studies and a network meta-analysis. Both systems showed lower fertilization rates compared to fresh oocytes. Open systems had lower cleavage and blastocyst formation rates, while closed systems showed no significant difference. Closed systems appear less harmful to oocyte competence, suggesting their potential for standardization in practice.

1. Introduction: Since the approval of oocyte vitrification in 2013, its use has increased significantly, replacing slow freezing due to superior outcomes. Vitrification, using ultrarapid cooling and high cryoprotectant concentrations, has applications in fertility preservation and donation programs. However, variations in protocols (e.g., open vs. closed systems) contribute to inconsistencies in results. Open systems offer ultrarapid freezing but risk contamination, while closed systems reduce contamination risk but may have slower cooling rates.

2. Methods: A systematic search of PubMed/MEDLINE and Cochrane Central Library databases identified 5,519 studies, narrowed to 23 based on inclusion criteria. Studies included prospective designs, focused on embryological (fertilization, cleavage, blastocyst rates) and clinical outcomes (pregnancy and live birth rates).

3. Results: The meta-analysis covered 27,204 oocytes. Open systems showed lower cleavage and blastocyst rates than fresh oocytes, while closed systems demonstrated similar outcomes to fresh. The cooling and warming rates of open systems may enhance developmental potential, but contamination concerns persist. Closed systems avoid contamination but may have slower cooling rates, impacting survival.

4. Discussion:

The study highlights the importance of refining vitrification protocols to improve oocyte and embryo developmental competence. Open systems, while achieving higher cooling rates, may negatively influence oocyte dynamics due to direct contact with liquid nitrogen. Closed systems provide added safety against contamination and show improved blastocyst formation rates, supporting their potential for broader clinical adoption.

5. Conclusion The primary focus of cryopreservation is evolving beyond immediate clinical outcomes to encompass neonatal and adult health implications of offspring conceived using vitrified oocytes. This meta-analysis revealed that while open and closed systems perform similarly in clinical outcomes, closed systems exhibit advantages in safety and blastocyst formation rates. These findings, coupled with the closed system's reduced contamination risk, highlight its potential for standardization in cryopreservation practices.

Further research should aim to clarify the biological effects of vitrification, focusing on understanding the mechanisms behind the differences observed between systems. Such efforts will guide the establishment of best practices, ensuring the safety and efficacy of cryopreservation as it continues to expand within assisted reproductive technologies.

Contact Us

For more information about our vitrification kits or cryogenic products / to place an order, please email us at info@cryolab.co.uk or visit https://cryolab.co.uk/ Source J Clin Med - PubMed 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

25L Onion Dewar with Tipping Trolley

    In the world of fertility and medical science, safe liquid nitrogen storage is critical. Whether you're storing embryos, semen samples, or oocytes, precision and reliability are non-negotiable. That’s where Cryolab’s 25L Onion Dewar with Tipping Trolley steps in—bringing strength, convenience, and cutting-edge design to the heart of every IVF laboratory. Trusted LN2 Storage for IVF Clinics Designed specifically for IVF liquid nitrogen storage, the Cryolab liquid nitrogen container offers unmatched reliability. Our 25L liquid nitrogen Dewar is part of a larger collection of Cryolab LN2 storage tanks, tailored to serve the evolving needs of fertility labs. Its robust, durable liquid nitrogen tank structure ensures maximum protection, while its lightweight LN2 Dewar design allows easy handling during high-pressure workdays. Built for Convenience: The Tipping Trolley Advantage Every Cryolab Dewar tank is equipped with an ergonomic tipping trolley for LN2, which offer...
Read more

Rethink Cryo Storage with CryoNest

Image
  Provides secure long-term cryopreservation of biological samples in liquid nitrogen When it comes to preserving eggs, sperm, embryos, and other biological samples, maintaining consistent ultra-low temperatures is non-negotiable. Liquid nitrogen storage tanks are the backbone of long-term cryopreservation in IVF clinics, fertility labs, research centres, and medical institutions. At Cryolab, we offer a complete range of cryogenic storage vessels engineered for both performance and safety covering everything from vertical LN₂ tanks and cryo storage containers to portable dry shippers. Built for Purpose Our cryogenic storage tanks are designed to meet a wide range of storage needs. Whether you’re managing embryo storage, sperm storage, or oocyte preservation, we provide options that include narrow-neck and wide-neck LN₂ tanks, available in both high-capacity and compact, space-saving formats. From low-evaporation models to tanks with extended holding times, every unit is developed w...
Read more

Spermtrack – Reusable Counting Chambers for Sustainable and Accurate Cell Analysis

In modern laboratories, the demand for accurate, efficient, and environmentally conscious solutions is greater than ever. The Spermtrack Reusable Counting Chambers are designed to meet these expectations, offering a sustainable and cost-effective alternative to disposable counting chambers. Whether you're working in an andrology lab, fertility clinic, or research setting, Spermtrack ensures precise results and long-term savings. Precision-Engineered for Consistency Spermtrack chambers are manufactured to deliver high-quality and reproducible results in every use. They are available in multiple configurations to meet the diverse needs of laboratory professionals: Available depths of 10 or 20 microns – with the 20-micron option conforming to WHO recommendations , ensuring alignment with global standards for semen analysis. Grid and non-grid options – allowing flexibility depending on your preferred counting method and laboratory protocols. Wit...
Read more